About Old Coach Pro Painting Sarasota & Manatee County’s Trusted Local Painters
An owner-run residential and commercial painting company built on reliability, transparent communication, and exceptional craftsmanship.
Our Story: A Painter Who Shows Up and Finishes
Ask a homeowner what they want most from a painting contractor, and the answer is rarely just about the paint. They want a professional who returns phone calls promptly, shows up on the exact day promised, protects their property with care, and stays on the job until the final bit of trim is pristine.
That exact standard is why Old Coach Pro Painting was founded.
Led by owner Corey Cunniff, our company takes a hands-on, owner-operated approach to every single project. With over 20 years of professional painting experience, Corey has personally transformed hundreds of homes across Florida—ranging from fresh new construction and historic Victorian restorations with intricate hand-detailed trim, to sun-bleached Florida stucco exteriors, modern kitchen cabinet makeovers, smooth skim-coated walls, and weathered backyard decks.
Rather than relying on rotating subcontractor crews where quality can slip, Corey leads the work directly.
Most of our work comes from referrals and repeat customers. We'd like to earn yours.
Book a free estimate
“Show up on time, protect the house, finish the job. That’s the whole playbook.” — Corey Cunniff, Owner
Our core values
How we run every residential and commercial painting job.
Transparent, written pricing
Clear, detailed estimates with zero hidden fees or surprise change orders halfway through your project. We treat your budget like our own.
Uncompromising craftsmanship
Meticulous surface preparation, razor-sharp paint lines, and premium paint products specifically chosen for Florida’s harsh climate. No shortcuts.
Strict schedule adherence
You get a reliable project timeline and proactive updates via text if weather or logistics shift our plan.
Immaculate job sites
Floors and furniture are thoroughly protected, and daily cleanup is standard practice—not just something we do on the final day.
Guaranteed satisfaction
We never pack up our gear until you’ve completed a final walkthrough and you are 100% happy with the results.
In our customers' own words
Frequently asked questions
Who owns Old Coach Pro Painting?
Old Coach Pro Painting is locally owned and operated by Corey Cunniff, who personally leads and oversees every painting project to ensure the highest standards of quality and craftsmanship.
What areas do you serve in Florida?
We provide residential and commercial painting services throughout Sarasota and Manatee Counties, including Bradenton, Lakewood Ranch, Parrish, Sarasota, Longboat Key, Siesta Key, Anna Maria Island, Venice, and surrounding communities.
Do you provide free estimates?
Yes! We offer free, detailed, written estimates for all interior painting, exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, popcorn ceiling removal, drywall repair, and deck staining projects.
Are you an owner-operated company or do you use subcontractors?
We are strictly owner-operated. Corey Cunniff leads the work directly on-site, ensuring consistent quality, clear communication, and accountability from start to finish.
Meet your local painting experts in Southwest Florida
Ready to give your home or business a fresh, professional look? Whether you're updating a single room, refreshing your home's exterior stucco, or refinishing your kitchen cabinets, we are here to help. Call or text Corey today at (561) 331-1412 to schedule your free written estimate across Sarasota and Manatee Counties.
Local painters for Sarasota & Manatee Counties
We're based in Bradenton and paint homes and businesses across Lakewood Ranch, Parrish, Longboat Key, Anna Maria Island, Sarasota and Siesta Key. Not on the list? Call or text. If you're close, we'll come out.
Manatee County
- Bradenton
- Lakewood Ranch
- Parrish
- Anna Maria Island
- Palmetto
- Ellenton
- Myakka City
- Cortez
- Palma Sola
Sarasota County
- Sarasota
- Longboat Key
- Siesta Key
- Venice
- Osprey
- Nokomis